The top 11 looks normal enough.
But theres a few WTF?? inclusions here.... Like Adam Warren at number 12? there's been literally 100s of similar mid-late college guys with middling stuff posting great ERAs in the NYPL over the past decade of which the have turned into just about 0 ML talent. Even worse maybe Kyle Conley and Ned Medchelli can anyone think of any mid round college OFs who tore up the NYPL that have turned into good ML players ? Also the young guys with crappy stats but good tools like Mr. Almanazar and such. I guess the question is was the depth really that bad that these guys made it or was the guy who wrote the list just picking an odd mix of old college guys with middling tools and good stats, older Foreign guys who really should be playing in the Full seasons if they want to have a career at this point like Paredes, Castro ect... and a Few Highly touted young guys who sucked like Almanazar or Hood. Despite the fact that these various types of players have shown to be pretty much never turn into good ML players?

Im a little surprised Gibson is ranked so low. The Paredes guy ranked just ahead of him seems to be similar but older and with crappier all around stats except a few points of batting average. Gibson actually walks alot and seems to have a good approach at the plate young guys who do that already tend to do much better than ones who can't get there walk totals in the teens.